HAZOP, HAZID, and SIL Study for Alkali Surfactant Polymer (ASP) Flood

Last updated: February 25, 2025

Introduction

HAL OFFSHORE has awarded iFluids Engineering to carry out HAZOP, HAZID & SIL study for CAIRN India at HAL OFFSHORE, Mumbai for its MWP 01 & 19 Alkali Surfactant Polymer (ASP) Flood at Barmer, Rajasthan as part of Process Hazard Analysis (PHA). Contract area RJ-ON-90/01 in the Indian state of Rajasthan is operated by Vedanta Limited, Cairn Oil & Gas, in a joint venture with ONGC.

CAIRN discovered oil and gas fields in RJON-90/01 block and named them Mangala, Aishwariya, Bhagyam, Saraswati, Shakti, Raageshwari, and others. The largest oil fields in the RJ block are those in the northern region, including Mangala, Bhagyam, and Aishwariya.

The Mangala Processing Terminal (MPT) in the Barmer district of Rajasthan processes the output from every well pad of Mangala, Bhagyam, Aishwariya, and other satellite fields.

Mangala is one of the major fields originally developed underwater flood and is currently under polymer flood. Based on the successful ASP Pilot trial in the Mangala field, Cairn intends to implement ASP flood as a part of the Mangala FM1 Layer in Mangala. As part of the early implementation plan, Well Pad 01 and 19 have been selected for Phase 1 ASP Flood Implementation.

The scope of work is to carry out Hazard and Operability (HAZOP), Hazard Identification (HAZID) & Safety Integrity Level (SIL) study for MWP 01 & 19 Alkali Surfactant Polymer (ASP) Flood at Barmer, Rajasthan.

What is a HAZOP

HAZOP is a systematic and qualitative technique used to check for deviations in the plant’s normal operating conditions which can lead to hazardous situations or operating issues in the plant. To identify risks and operational disruptions in the plant, guidewords (low, high, less, more) were utilized with data like pressure, temperature, flow rate, and level.

Key Aspects of HAZOP Analysis

Any facility’s HAZOP study provides information on both the plant’s general safety features and daily operations. The following list includes some of HAZOP’s key characteristics.

Infographic displaying the key aspects of HAZOP (Hazard and Operability) analysis, including Hazard Identification, Safety Recommendations, Equipment & Instrument Hazards, HAZOP in Design & Procurement, and Safety Investigations & Safeguards
Key Aspects of HAZOP Analysis
  • Identification of hazards and operating problems.
  • To recommend changes in design, procedure, etc to improve safety.
  •  Identification of hazards from equipment failure, instrument malfunction, and operational issues
  •  A HAZOP analysis is conducted during the design and procurement stages to thoroughly review the P&ID and find any variations from standard procedures that could result in operational problems or risks.
  • HAZOP can be used to recommend safety investigations for effects that cannot be avoided by applying current safeguards or by suggesting new safeguards, in addition to these other uses.

What is a HAZID

Hazard Identification (HAZID) Study is a structured and systematic evaluation of a planned and/or existing operation to identify and evaluate potential hazards in design and operation. A team of experts from different disciplines carries out this study. The team looks at each section of a facility and analyses its consequences against any existing safeguards.  The effects of the identified risks on property, safety, and the environment are evaluated.

Objectives of the HAZID

The objectives of the HAZID study include:

Infographic illustrating the objectives of HAZID (Hazard Identification) with key elements including Identification of Hazardous Events, Risk Quantification, Safety Precaution Assessment, Residual Hazard Analysis, and Health & Environmental Impact Assessment
Objectives of HAZID
  • Detecting potentially dangerous internal and external events that, if they occur, could endanger people, property, and the environment.
  • Quantitatively evaluate the risks associated with the identified hazard occurrences and their propensity to occur.
  • Assess the safety precautions suggested in preventing, mitigating, and controlling the potentially dangerous results.
  • Identifying the remaining hazardous events that require additional quantitative assessment and analysis.
  • Identification of health and environmental impacts associated with the Project.

A structured method to ascertain the probable effects of the following is required for the HAZID:

  • The surroundings of the facilities
  • The facilities in their surroundings
  • The facilities on health.

What is a SIL

As per the scope of the SIL Classification study, safety instrumented functions (SIFs) were identified in the P&IDs and the C&E matrices, relevant to the project, having the main objectives:

  • Identify potential risks to the people, environment, and assets due to the failure of Safety Related Systems and associated facilities in the plant to operate on demand.
  • Establish the fundamental performance standards for all safety-related instrumented equipment to “As Low as Reasonably Practically” to reduce the aforementioned hazards.

SIL Methodology

SIL Methodology is discussed below: 

Infographic listing key elements of Safety Integrity Function (SIF) analysis, including Identification of SIF Loops, Initiating Causes & Likelihood, Scenario Consequence & Severity, Independent Protection Layers (IPLs), SIL Requirement Analysis, and SIS Recommendations
SIL Methodology
  • Identify all Safety Integrity Function (SIF) loops from the Cause and Effect diagram (C&E) and HAZOP report
  • Identify initiating causes and their initiating likelihood
  • Determine the scenario consequence level and severity concerning people, environment, and assets
  • List out the independent protection layers (IPLs) that can mitigate the initiating causes
  • Calculate the Probability of Failure on Demand (PFD) and in turn, analyze the SIL requirement
  • Provide recommendations if there is an additional Safety Instrumented System (SIS) required

Summary

HAZOP, HAZID & SIL study for the ASP flood project of CAIRN Oil & Gas was conducted in the presence of a multi-disciplinary team from various departments such as Process Engineering, Process Safety, Projects, Instrumentation, Maintenance, Electrical, etc.

Facilities covered for above mentioned safety assessments are

  •  Mangala well pad – 01 (MP-01)
  •  Mangala well pad – 12 (MP-12)
  •  Mangala well pad – 19 (MP-19)
  •  Sulphate Removal Plant (SRP)

HAZOP, HAZID & SIL study findings were recorded by the team and suitable recommendations were also made based on the mutual discussion among the team members. HAZOP & HAZID was conducted unit-wise using basic engineering documents like PFD, P&ID, Process Design Basis (PDB) & plot plan whereas the SIL study was followed by HAZOP using P&IDs and Cause & Effect (C&E) diagrams.  Based on the session’s conclusions, recommendations were made. Additionally, some broad suggestions for the entire institution were put up.

Conclusion

The HAZOP, HAZID, and SIL studies play a crucial role in ensuring the safety and reliability of ASP Flood projects by systematically identifying hazards, assessing risks, and verifying safety integrity levels. By implementing these studies, industries can enhance process safety, minimize operational risks, and comply with safety regulations. The findings and recommendations from these assessments help in optimizing design, improving safeguards, and ensuring a safer working environment.

Why Choose Our HAZOP, HAZID & SIL Services?

Industry-Recognized Experts: A team of certified professionals with extensive experience in safety risk assessments.
Comprehensive Risk Mitigation: We identify and eliminate potential risks before they escalate into major safety incidents.
Regulatory Compliance: Adherence to API, IEC, NFPA, and ISO safety standards to meet industry requirements.
Advanced Safety Tools & Techniques: Cutting-edge software and methodologies for precise risk analysis and SIL determination.
Customized Safety Solutions: Tailored reports and action plans based on your facility’s specific needs.